LIFESTYLE
Does your music make depression worse?Ā
Maria Gaian, Soul HealerĀ & Music Lover
Have you ever been dumped by a lover and spent hours playing certain songs on repeat?
We all seem to have our favourite āgo toā songs for when we feel sad, lost, betrayed, grieving and in pain.
They usually have lyrics that reflect our feelings.
Words about how we canāt live without that person in our life, weāll always love them, weāll never find anyone else, we donāt want anyone else.
You know the stuff.
Thereās a huge catalogue of songs that reflect our feelings.
I love music and when I was depressed, I played certain songs on repeat.
The more melancholy the music was, the more I liked it.
But it didnāt make me feel better.
Although the lyrics reflected how I felt and I took comfort that someone seemed to understand me, it never lifted my mood.
Did my music make depression worse?Ā
It was only when I started to recover that I found out what the right music could do for me.
A couple of things happened that gave me food for thought.
Believe it or not, a song by Jennifer Lopez saved my life.
I was considering whether to give up and let depression win, or whether to fight for my life and do everything I could to heal my wounds when her song āDance Againā played on the radio.
The lyrics are,
āI wanna dance and love and dance againā
Tears streaming down my face, I knew then and there that I DID want to dance and love again, so I made the choice to fight for myself and my recovery.
It was a powerful moment for me and one that changed everything.
When I built a playlist on YouTube, things started to change for me.
Iād started the recovery process and I was writing about what happened to me and my feelings about it.
I like to work with music in the background, so I began building a playlist on YouTube.Ā Ā
The playlist was filled with 70ās, 80ās and 90ās music that brought back someĀ good memories.
I also added the current songs of the time that feltĀ positive andĀ empowering, such as Katy Perryās āRoarā and Kelly Clarksonās āStrongerā.
As I built the playlist, two things became apparent.
The first was that I was seeing past my current horrendous situation andĀ reliving good memoriesĀ that came back to me via the soundtrack of my life at the time.
It reminded me that my life wasnāt always like this, Iād had better days and it made me feel like thoseĀ better days could return.Ā
Secondly, listening to positive, happy, musicĀ made me feel upbeatĀ and it began to empower me.
Being the victim of the cruelty and vindictiveness of a group of people who did not even know me was hard, but it felt a lot less serious when I listened toĀ āMeanā by Taylor Swift.
Now I understood that their words didnāt have to make any difference to my life at all if I chose not to let them in.
I found my strength singing along to the words.
It might sound silly, but music is way more powerful than we realise.
Music isnāt just some fluffy, meaningless thing.
It makes a huge difference to us on so many levels.
There’s no doubt about it, music can make depression worse.Ā
My own findings are backed up by loads of research.
Listening to upbeat music: āĀ
ā„Ā increases heart rate;
ā lowers stress levels;
ā and increases immunity to illness;
so it isnāt just good for the mind and Soul, but for the body as well.
Music therapy is currently being used to not only beat depression, but also to help with dementia, amnesia, schizophrenia, and other mood disorders.
It can help with communication issues as well.
Autistic folks are finding an outlet through playing percussion instruments under the guidance of a music therapist.
Scientists have proven thatĀ music doesnāt just alter our mood, but can even change our mindset and perception.
The power of music goes even deeper! Letās get scientific for a second.
In an article inĀ Science Daily, it was reported that:-
ālistening to a sad or happy song on the radio can make you feel more sad or happyā¦.such mood changes not only affect how you feel, they also change your perception. For example,Ā people will recognize happy faces if they are feeling happy themselves.ā
And a study by researcher Jacob Jolij and student Maaike Meurs of the Psychology Department of the University of Groningen shows that music has an even more dramatic effect on perception:-
āEven if there is nothing to see, people sometimes still see happy faces when they are listening to happy music and sad faces when they are listening to sad music.”e
The researchers ran an experiment where they showed smileys to people whilst playing either sad or happy music.
They asked the people to interpret whether the smileys were happy or sad.
When the people were listening to the happy music, they interpreted more of the images as being happy and when the music was sad, they interpreted more of them as being sad.
More surprising and very interesting is the fact that:-
āeven when no smiley at all was shown, the subjects often thought they recognized a happy smiley when listening to happy music and a sad one when listening to sad music.ā
Jolij said:-
āSeeing things that are not there is the result of top-down processes in the brain.
Conscious perception is largely based on these top-down processes: your brain continuously compares the information that comes in through your eyes with what it expects on the basis of what you know about the world. The final result of this comparison process is what we eventually experience as reality.ā
He added that:-
āOur research results suggest that the brain builds up expectations not just on the basis of experience but on your mood as well.ā
University of Groningen. (2011, April 27). Music changes perception, research shows. ScienceDaily. Retrieved April 17, 2014 fromĀ www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2011/04/110427101606.htm
This research really brings it home.
Iām going to repeat that last sentence.
āThe brain builds up expectation not just on the basis of experience but on your MOOD as wellā
Most depression is caused by perception and expectation, so this is really important information if we want to heal and thrive.
It’s up to you. Are you going to let your music make depression worse? Or are you willing to choose the right music to help you to ditch the black dog?Ā
Now I know from my personal experience that when youāre going through a deep crisis period, it feels impossible to be in a good mood.
Iāve suffered with severe clinical depression and I know how hard it is to see the good in anything when youāre ill.
You canāt help feeling the āblack dogā even when you feel like you shouldnāt have any reason to feel down.
(My advice if youāre in this position currently, is to go and see your GP and find out your options.)
How can you possibly feel good when you’re suffering from depression?
Or if your life is undergoing drastic change and falling apart at the seams?Ā Ā
Why would you be smiling and happy?
Sounds ridiculous, doesnāt it?
But remember, your thoughts and beliefs are not permanently fixed.
You can change them.
Youāre more likely to: āĀ
ā„ make better decisions;
⦠think rationally;
ā„ spend less time dwelling on your problems;
if you can lift your mood.Ā
There are more reasons why you need to be careful what music you listen to!
M.Farouk Radwan, MSc on his websiteĀ 2knowmyself.comĀ has found thatĀ people who listen to sad songs after breakups recover 10 times slower than those who donāt.
Pretty shocking, right?
Even more alarming is the statement that:-
āSome songs contain negative words and phrases that are much more destructive than negative self-talk.ā
As someone whoās fascinated by psychology, Iāve discovered that the mind listens to what we tell it.
It also learns by repetition which is why positive affirmations and hypnotherapy recordings that repeat instructions work so well.
Every time we listen to, or sing along with a song, the lyrics are being soaked up by our minds.
Songs contain messages that program your mind and result in you creating new beliefs.
By consistently repeating a negative message over and over, the mind believes it.
āA popular example would be any love song that contains a phrase like:-
āI canāt go on without youā.
The more you listen to this song, the more youāre programming your mind with this belief.
Youāre more likely to end up feeling desperate when you break up with someone.ā
I must confess that I love affirmations and I spend all day telling myself: ā
āI can do thisā
and reminding myself that
Iām worthy,
intelligent,
resourceful,
and loved.
Yet I never considered that when Iām singing along to sad and negative songs Iām reinforcing messages that might be undoing all my hard work.
Itās really made me mindful about what Iām listening to and what Iām singing along with.
If you want to read more from M Farouk Fadwan MSc, just click here: Music Therapy Changes Mood
Turn off the melancholy music whilst you are feeling low or struggling and play uplifting, empowering music instead.
Ā
Let it inspire you to find a way to get the hell up off the floor and start finding ways to get through your crisis.
Thereās something good around the corner and it will come more quickly to you if you feel positive and are able to take action, rather than dwelling on your situation and feeling totally helpless.
Iām NOT saying that you have to chuck all your music out.
Iāll always listen to the beautiful songs of Amy Lee and Evanescence and Linkin Park, but Iām mindful of when I play them.
The last thing any of want to do is play music that can make depression worse!
So before you crank up your playlist, ask yourself: –
Do I feel a bit low?
Am I on the border of feeling sad and could that music make depression worse and send me over the edge?
Or am I doing something positive that just needs a soundtrack that I love, whether sad or not?
I played Evanescence whilst decorating my new office space.
The music didnāt lower my mood because the pleasure I was taking in creating a fantastic new space for myself balanced it out.
Let music inspire you!
I use music to lift me first thing in the morning if Iām struggling to get going at work.
And in the afternoon, when I tend to slump, a good disco track works better than caffeine to wake me back up!
Iām often doing the āoffice chair shuffleā when Iām working.
In fact, Iām boogying to Justin Timberlakeās āCanāt Stop The Feelingā as I write this.
Iām pretty sure it stops my shoulders getting tight.
Cos donāt forget, music isnāt just good for the soul, itās good for your body, too!Ā
Remember what I said before about the evidence that listening to upbeat music increases heart rate, lower stress levels, and increases immunity to illness.Ā
Dancing to music is one of the easiest ways to get some exercise, especially if youāre confined to your home.Ā
Crank up the stereo, sunbeam!
Itās time to dance!
I hope that you enjoyed this post and that itās given you some food for thought.
Does your music make depression worse? Or do you use music to make yourself feel better? What are your favourite tracks to listen to?
If you want to talk about this, come over to my Substack. Comments are open and we can chat.Ā
Until next time,
My Challenge to You:
Take a look at the music you listen to on a regular basis.
What lyrics are you repeating over and over to yourself?
Make sure that theyāre words that you want to reflect and not words that are inadvertently affecting your mind.
Try listening to only positive and upbeat music for 21 days and let me know how you feel at the end!
Why not have a mess about on YouTube and create your own inspiring soundtracks with videos, or make playlists on your MP3 that contain only fun, upbeat, inspiring and motivational music?
If you want some inspiration, check out my playlist on YouTube.
Some tracks are current, some are a bit kitsch and some are classic anthems.
Why not come over and get your daily dose of dance therapy?
Learn More
About the Author
Maria GaianMaria Gaianis a Gaian Witch, Nature Therapist and Intuitive Soul and Energy Healer specialising in depression recovery.